The Muhlenberg softball team of the decade 2010-11 to 2019-20:

First Team
C          Amelia Shelley (2015-18)
1B        Kelly Kline (2011-14) 
2B        Erica Wenzel (2011-14)
SS        Kristina Qualben (2016-19)
3B        Karissa Astrella (2015-18)
OF       Taylor Trifiolis (2013-16) 
OF       Alyssa Schell (2012-15) 
OF       Devon Barber (2011-13) 
DP       Kristy Selby (2016-19)
UT       Ashley Brewer (2011)
P          Kelsey Jones (2012-15) 
P          Haley Fedak (2015-18)
 
Honorable Mention
Hanna Caiola (2015-18)
Nicole Iannarone (2013-16)
Genna Cicchetti (2019-20)
Brittany Dzieciolowski (2013-14)
 

---

Shelley was a three-time All-Centennial Conference catcher, earning second-team honors in both 2015 and 2017.

The Mules' all-time leader in numerous categories, including hits, home runs, RBI and slugging percentage, Kline was CC player of the year in 2012 and a three-time all-region selection.

Wenzel, the program's all-time leader in runs scored, was the only Muhlenberg position player to earn back-to-back first-team All-CC nods in the decade.

We took some liberties with the positions of the next three players. Qualben played shortstop as a freshman in 2016 but earned All-CC recognition as a third baseman. Astrella played a variety of positions (including third base in 2016), earning All-CC honors as a utility player and second baseman.

Trifiolis received All-CC honorable mention as an outfielder as a freshman but had her best season playing second base, earning first-team honors there as a senior.

Schell, Barber and Selby all made the All-CC team twice - second team once and honorable mention once. Schell and Barber were members of the 2013 team that set a College record for all sports with 31 wins.

Brewer repeated as CC player of the year in 2011, when she hit .409 with seven homers and had a 2.61 ERA in the circle. She also earned third-team Academic All-America honors that year.

The 2013 CC pitcher of the year, Jones went 31-8 with a 2.00 ERA over a dominant two-year stretch.

Fedak earned second-team All-CC honors as a utility player in 2018. Her top feat: pitching a shutout and hitting a grand slam in the same game. 

Outfielders Caiola (2016) and Iannarone (2014) were named to the All-CC second team once apiece.

Cicchetti was the Mules' first CC Gold Glove recipient, winning the honor as a catcher in 2019.

Another catcher, Dzieciolowski, led Muhlenberg in mispronunciations and was a two-time All-CC pick.